Published on 9/10/2017 10:47:16 AM | Source: Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd

RBI reviews working of MCLR - Motilal Oswal

RBI reviews working of MCLR

The unsatiated desire for perfect lending rate regime


RBI reviews working of MCLR – earnings/margin volatility to increase

The RBI working group has found monetary policy transmission to be inadequate under the current MCLR/base rate regime. This is more so in the case of outstanding loans, wherein the longer reset period and the discretionary spreads being charged by banks have prevented proper pass-through of reduction in lending rates. Besides, the computation of base rate and MCLR has also been found to be inconsistent among banks thus putting borrowers at a disadvantage. The group also highlighted that monetary transmission remains asymmetric over the monetary policy cycles – higher during the tightening phase and lower during the easing phase, irrespective of the interest rate methodology being followed. The working group has thus suggested that banks need to move to one of the following external benchmarks – (i) T-Bill rate, (ii) CD rate and (iii) repo rate to price their loans, after due consultation with the RBI and other stakeholders. Also, the group suggested that the external benchmark should be adopted from 1 April 2018, and thereafter, all existing loans (BPLR/base rate/MCLR) should be moved to the new benchmark within one year (i.e. by March 2019).


Our view:

We believe that the migration to the suggested methodology will bring in more volatility to spreads/profitability of banks across cycles as they transparently pass on the revised lending rates to the borrowers. Thus, banks’ margins will likely expand during monetary tightening cycle and vice versa. We believe that in order to protect profitability across cycles, banks – particularly private banks –will work toward faster repricing of deposits, which the retail depositors will need to adjust to. This may result in higher volatility in margins, particularly for retail banks, as they have higher share of fixed rate assets and CASA deposits. We further note that such a migration will also have an impact on the strategy of a bank, as by benchmarking the lending rate to an external variable, the regulator will essentially delineate the asset and liability profile of a bank. We note that there have been several banks that have planned for an adequate liability franchise before rolling out the retail asset products. The suggested migration may take away the interest rate stickiness of even SA deposits, and thus, may require further strategy deliberations on building retail franchise by these banks.


To Read Complete Report & Disclaimer Click Here


For More Motilal Oswal Securities Ltd  Disclaimer SEBI Registration number is INH000000412


Above views are of the author and not of the website kindly read disclaimer